At The Courthouse Hotel, we’re proud to be more than just a pub — we’re a local.
Since reopening, we’ve been blown away by the support from the Smythesdale community and the steady stream of familiar faces walking back through our doors week after week.
So what makes people keep coming back?
Here are 5 reasons we hear all the time — and why we work hard to keep delivering on them:
1. The Food’s Just Real
We’re not about fancy garnishes or complicated menus — we’re about food you actually want to eat.
Our parmas are done properly. Our pies are loaded with flavour. The burgers hit the spot. And if you’re after something lighter or vegetarian, we’ve got great options too.
We serve honest pub food, made well, and that’s exactly what people come back for.
2. The Staff Actually Care
We’ve built a team that’s friendly, down-to-earth, and genuinely wants to make your visit a good one.
Whether you’ve booked a table for ten or just walked in for a pint, we greet you like you belong — because you do.
Customers often tell us that the service feels personal, not robotic. That’s no accident — it’s part of who we are.
3. Something for Everyone
Whether you’re here for a quiet dinner, a casual family catch-up, a Sunday session with friends, or a hens night in full swing — we’ve got a space and vibe to match.
The menu suits all sorts. The drinks list hits all the right notes. And the layout gives everyone their own spot — without losing that warm pub feel.
4. Events That Don’t Feel Forced
From trivia nights to live music and the occasional Sunday party, we run events that feel natural — not forced.
You won’t see overhyped flyers for empty rooms. When we run something, it’s because we know people will actually enjoy it.
We listen to feedback, we try new things, and we’re always focused on what our locals will love — not just what trends online.
5. It Feels Like a Local Should
A pub is more than just a place to get a meal or a drink — it’s a place where you feel known.
It’s where the team remembers your favourite table. Where someone says “hey” when you walk in.
It’s not about being flashy — it’s about being familiar.
And that’s why people keep coming back.
